What Dog Food Brands Should You Avoid? How to Vet Any Brand

"What dog food brands should I stay away from?" gets searched constantly. You won't get a blacklist from us. Brands change owners, factories and recipes, and a list written today can be wrong by spring.

What we can give you is better: the questions we ask before any brand earns shelf space at Slobberbones. Use them on any bag, from any store.

1. Who Formulates the Food?

A good brand employs a qualified pet nutritionist: someone with a PhD in animal nutrition or a board-certified veterinary nutritionist. Not a marketing team. Not a celebrity. Not "our founder's grandma's recipe."

How to check: look on their website. If you can't find it, email them. Good brands answer that question without hesitation.

2. Where Is It Made, and Who Makes It?

Some brands own their manufacturing plants. Others hire a co-packer that makes food for a dozen other labels. Co-packing isn't automatically bad, but brands that control their own production have more control over quality.

3. How Was "Complete and Balanced" Proven?

The AAFCO statement on the back tells you one of two things:

  • "Formulated to meet" AAFCO nutrient profiles: the recipe hits the numbers on paper.

  • "Animal feeding tests" using AAFCO procedures: dogs ate the food and the results were measured.

Both are legitimate. Feeding trials are an extra step that shows the brand put the food in front of real dogs.

4. What Does Their Quality Control Look Like?

Ask whether they test ingredients when they arrive and finished food before it ships. Ask what they test for. Brands with strong programs are proud to tell you about them.

5. What's Their Recall History?

The FDA keeps a public list of pet food recalls. A single recall years ago, handled quickly and transparently, isn't a dealbreaker. A pattern of them, or a slow and evasive response, is.

6. Will They Talk to You?

Call the customer service number on the bag. Ask any question from this list. You'll learn a lot from how the call goes. A brand that's proud of its food is happy to explain it.

Red Flags Worth Noting

  • Heavy marketing language with little detail ("ancestral," "premium," "gourmet" with nothing to back it up)

  • Unnamed meat sources or artificial colors on the ingredient list

  • No way to contact a real person

  • Claims that the food cures or prevents disease (that's a vet's job, not a bag's)

Why We Do This Homework

Big box stores carry what sells. We carry what passes. Every brand on our shelves has been through these questions, and the ones that didn't pass aren't here. That's what "hand-curated" means at Slobberbones. Read more in How We Actually Pick What Goes On Our Shelves.

Have a brand you're unsure about? Ask us. If we carry it, we'll tell you why. If we don't, we'll tell you that too. Stop by the shop or browse our vetted lineup at slobberbones.com/shop.

Next
Next

What Is the Healthiest Dog Food? An Honest Answer